Health Dept Magazine Health Dept Magazine

25Nov/10Off

What should I get, Skin iD, Murad, or Proactiv?



I'm really wanting to get Skin iD. I have never known anybody who used Murad, but I heard it's good. I've had friends and family members whom Proactiv worked miracles for.


Which should I try? My skin is fairly light, it gets some red acne, many blackheads on my nose and chin, a really bad forehead under my hairline, and sometimes all over my chin.


Comments (12) Trackbacks (0)
  1. Have you gone to dermatolgist? I think that is your best bet.

  2. proactiv. it works the best

  3. go clearasil ultra. it worked way better than any of those

  4. skin id because if you dont use pro activ for like one day you will break out and besides on all of there commercials they are all wearing makeup skin id

  5. I’ve heard good things about proactive

  6. Definitely Proactiv,works wonders.

  7. when I was growing up my parents made me use facial scrub twice a day and it worked. Instead of wasting money on such so called cures try using facial scrub when you awake and before you go to bed. all acne is is over production of skin oil mixed with dead skin cells and common dirt collected on the skin.

  8. I have alwyas wanted to use proactive, but one day i came to school and i saw a girl that ususally have glwoing skin and her face was REDD i saw her later in the bathroom and she was talkign to her friends and said she had used proactive and she got an allergic reaction from it, so ask a dermatologist.

  9. I’ve tried Murad and Proactive & from the sound of it our acne is similar :P

    Proactive irritated my skin
    made it redder and sensitive even when I cut back & my acne did not change at all but it helped (a bit) with blackheads the only thing good about proactive is the face mask
    and personally I don’t know anyone who has tried proactive and had it work "wonders"

    Murad after 4 weeks cleared my face entirely! I had NOT A SINGLE pimple!
    i was shocked and it also calms redness and feels really great
    but it did not help with black heads
    after 4 &1/2 weeks I ran out of the face wash
    and my face broke out worse then before
    tried the system again but added the Murad astringent and it was little help :(

    I would say go to a dermatologist instead save your money and time that’s what I’m about to do plus if you go to a dermatologist now you can avoid TRYING out all these products and can keep yourself from getting pock marks and scars by using something that actually works

    but out of the three go Murad- Skin ID uses 10% benzoyl peroxide which may dry out or irritate your skin too much and if you do make sure you continue it’s use without a break

  10. i`ll say proactive because it works really fast and it`s works.

  11. Murad works so well! You can buy it at Sephora or from Sephora’s website. The clarifying cleanser cleared my skin. I actually used Clinique Acne Solutions toner, and a drugstore acne treatment (clean and clear) and moisturizer (Shiseido) with it.

    Do you wear makeup or sunscreen? If so, consider using a makeup remover prior to your face wash. I use Shu Uemura cleansing oil, but Clinique’s Take the Day Off and drugstore wipes work just fine. This step made all of the difference for me, because without makeup/sunscreen in my pores, my cleanser could actually clear my skin.

  12. I would recommend Acneace!!!!
    I used it, and after 3 months, my acne was COMPLETELY gone!
    Hope it works for you :)


Leave a comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Trackbacks are disabled.

Powered by Yahoo! Answers